Bang H8! PUZZLE #1 - SOLUTION The six cookies are: Fig Newton Fudge Stripe Graham Cracker Nilla Wafer Nutter Butter Ritz Cracker After filling in the grid with the cookie names, the blue, green and pink boxes contain groups of letters that anagram to: WHITE COW DRINK. Now, cows drink water, 'tis true, but the white cow drink we had in mind was MILK.